Tuesday, October 15, 2013

Berlin museum seeks return of ancient gold tablet

A Holocaust survivor's family urged New York's highest court Tuesday to let them keep an ancient gold tablet that their late father somehow obtained in Germany after World War II.
Attorney Steven Schlesinger argued that the estate of Riven Flamenbaum has a legal claim, whether the native of Poland bought the relic from a Russian soldier or simply took it to compensate for losing his family at Auschwitz, the concentration camp where he spent several years.
"Under the Soviet rules at the time, there was permission to pillage and plunder," Schlesinger said. "My client could have taken it in retribution."
The tablet was in the collection of the Vorderasiatisches Museum, a branch of the Pergamon Museum in Berlin, before the war. The family argued that the museum's failure to reclaim the tablet for 60 years was an unreasonable delay, undercutting its claim. Schlesinger said Flamenbaum had been told by Christie's in 1954 that the small tablet was a fake and kept it at home. It's now in a safety deposit box on Long Island.
Museum attorney Raymond Dowd said the absence of the 3,200-year-old relic was quickly noted by the museum, later reported by scholars and widely known.
"There's no such thing as a right of pillage," Dowd said. "Reparation has nothing to do with this case."
Who gets it is up to New York's Court of Appeals, where the seven judges grilled both lawyers Tuesday. A ruling is expected next month.
The 9.5-gram tablet was excavated a century ago by German archaeologists from the Ishtar Templein what is now northern Iraq. It went on display in Berlin in 1934, was put in storage as the war began and later disappeared.
"It could fit in the palm of your hand," said Hannah Flamenbaum. "We played with it as children."
Her father met her mother, another Holocaust survivor, at a relocation camp after the war. By his accounts he traded cigarettes or a salami for it. The couple came to the U.S., where her father went to work for a Manhattan liquor store and later bought the store, settling in Brooklyn, raising three children and later moving to Long Island, she said.
"He never tried to sell it. ... This was sort of the legacy of his suffering in the camps," she said. "The thought was if we're allowed to retain it, put it on display in one of the museums, whether down here in Battery Park City in Manhattan or even in Israel. Use it as a way to talk about the Holocaust ... and my parents' story."

Genesis GCQD38A 3 8 Inch Close Quarter Drill

Genesis GCQD38A 3 8 Inch Close Quarter Drill

Reviews Genesis GCQD38A 3 8 Inch Close Quarter Drill

Black Decker 14 4 Volt Cordless Drill Driver Tool Only

Black Decker 14 4 Volt Cordless Drill Driver Tool Only

Reviews Black Decker 14 4 Volt Cordless Drill Driver Tool Only

SKIL 2354 06 Compact 4V Max Lithium Ion Driver with 5 Piece Bit Set Pink

SKIL 2354 06 Compact 4V Max Lithium Ion Driver with 5 Piece Bit Set Pink

Reviews SKIL 2354 06 Compact 4V Max Lithium Ion Driver with 5 Piece Bit Set Pink

DEWALT DW217 6 7 Amp 1 4 Inch Drill

DEWALT DW217 6 7 Amp 1 4 Inch Drill

Reviews DEWALT DW217 6 7 Amp 1 4 Inch Drill

Ingersoll Rand 117 Standard Duty Air Hammer

Ingersoll Rand 117 Standard Duty Air Hammer

Reviews Ingersoll Rand 117 Standard Duty Air Hammer

Factory Reconditioned RYOBI ZRHP496 9 6 Volt 3 8 Inch Cordless Drill Driver Kit

Factory Reconditioned RYOBI ZRHP496 9 6 Volt 3 8 Inch Cordless Drill Driver Kit

Reviews Factory Reconditioned RYOBI ZRHP496 9 6 Volt 3 8 Inch Cordless Drill Driver Kit

Factory Reconditioned Bosch SG45 RT 4500 RPM Drywall Screwgun

Factory Reconditioned Bosch SG45 RT 4500 RPM Drywall Screwgun

Reviews Factory Reconditioned Bosch SG45 RT 4500 RPM Drywall Screwgun

Ampro AR2432 3 8 Inch Angle Head Reversible Air Drill

Ampro AR2432 3 8 Inch Angle Head Reversible Air Drill

Reviews Ampro AR2432 3 8 Inch Angle Head Reversible Air Drill

Drill Variable Speed 3 8 In

Drill Variable Speed 3 8 In

Reviews Drill Variable Speed 3 8 In

Hitachi WR18DBDL 18V Cordless Lithium Ion Brushless 1 2 in Impact Wrench

Hitachi WR18DBDL 18V Cordless Lithium Ion Brushless 1 2 in Impact Wrench

Reviews Hitachi WR18DBDL 18V Cordless Lithium Ion Brushless 1 2 in Impact Wrench

Bosch 11304 Demolition Hammer Replacement Hex Socket Head Cap Screw 2910141248 2 PACK

Bosch 11304 Demolition Hammer Replacement Hex Socket Head Cap Screw 2910141248 2 PACK

Reviews Bosch 11304 Demolition Hammer Replacement Hex Socket Head Cap Screw 2910141248 2 PACK

Dewalt Metal Impact Drill 10 X 101 6Mm

Dewalt Metal Impact Drill 10 X 101 6Mm

Reviews Dewalt Metal Impact Drill 10 X 101 6Mm

Makita LS1016L 10 Inch Dual Slide Compound Miter Saw with Laser

Makita LS1016L 10 Inch Dual Slide Compound Miter Saw with Laser

Reviews Makita LS1016L 10 Inch Dual Slide Compound Miter Saw with Laser

Rip Guide

Rip Guide

Reviews Rip Guide

PORTER CABLE PC75TRS 7 5 Amp Reciprocating Saw

PORTER CABLE PC75TRS 7 5 Amp Reciprocating Saw

Reviews PORTER CABLE PC75TRS 7 5 Amp Reciprocating Saw

Factory Reconditioned Ryobi ZRCSB142LZK 7 1 4 Inch Dual Laser Circular Saw

Factory Reconditioned Ryobi ZRCSB142LZK 7 1 4 Inch Dual Laser Circular Saw

Reviews Factory Reconditioned Ryobi ZRCSB142LZK 7 1 4 Inch Dual Laser Circular Saw

Ryobi Table Saw RTS10

Ryobi Table Saw RTS10

Reviews Ryobi Table Saw RTS10

GMC LS4PJUL 4 Amp Pendulum Action Jigsaw with REDEYE

GMC LS4PJUL 4 Amp Pendulum Action Jigsaw with REDEYE

Reviews GMC LS4PJUL 4 Amp Pendulum Action Jigsaw with REDEYE

Northern Industrial Wet Tile Saw 7in Blade Size

Northern Industrial Wet Tile Saw 7in Blade Size

Reviews Northern Industrial Wet Tile Saw 7in Blade Size

Factory Reconditioned Bosch 1587AVSK 46 Top Handle Jig Saw Kit

Factory Reconditioned Bosch 1587AVSK 46 Top Handle Jig Saw Kit

Reviews Factory Reconditioned Bosch 1587AVSK 46 Top Handle Jig Saw Kit

Milwaukee 6470 21 10 1 4 Circular Saw

Milwaukee 6470 21 10 1 4 Circular Saw

Reviews Milwaukee 6470 21 10 1 4 Circular Saw

G FORCE 50116 Circular Saw 18V 5 3 8 inch

G FORCE 50116 Circular Saw 18V 5 3 8 inch

Reviews G FORCE 50116 Circular Saw 18V 5 3 8 inch

Threaded Needle 22 G 1 2 In L PK 50

Threaded Needle 22 G 1 2 In L PK 50

Reviews Threaded Needle 22 G 1 2 In L PK 50

125 Amp 70 Air Cooled TIG Torch Body With Gas Control Valve

125 Amp 70 Air Cooled TIG Torch Body With Gas Control Valve

Reviews 125 Amp 70 Air Cooled TIG Torch Body With Gas Control Valve

Chicago Pneumatic CP881 Heavy Duty Air Reciprocating Saw

Chicago Pneumatic CP881 Heavy Duty Air Reciprocating Saw

Reviews Chicago Pneumatic CP881 Heavy Duty Air Reciprocating Saw

Versa Tool MB3A3B3C3D1H1I1J Universal Oscillating Saw Blade Kit 15 Piece 7 Blade Type Variety Pack

Versa Tool MB3A3B3C3D1H1I1J Universal Oscillating Saw Blade Kit 15 Piece 7 Blade Type Variety Pack

Reviews Versa Tool MB3A3B3C3D1H1I1J Universal Oscillating Saw Blade Kit 15 Piece 7 Blade Type Variety Pack

1 8 X 36 R60 Radnor RG60 Carbon Steel Bare Gas Welding Rod 50 Pound Box Set of 50

1 8 X 36 R60 Radnor RG60 Carbon Steel Bare Gas Welding Rod 50 Pound Box Set of 50

Reviews 1 8 X 36 R60 Radnor RG60 Carbon Steel Bare Gas Welding Rod 50 Pound Box Set of 50

BASE FULL ROUND 51MM OXY BRASS

BASE FULL ROUND 51MM OXY BRASS

Reviews BASE FULL ROUND 51MM OXY BRASS

Series 1 Type GPN One Piece Cutting Tips 6 gpn cutting tipe n gas

Series 1 Type GPN One Piece Cutting Tips 6 gpn cutting tipe n gas

Reviews Series 1 Type GPN One Piece Cutting Tips 6 gpn cutting tipe n gas

10 Pack 1 5 Lanthanated Tungsten Welding Rods 1 8x7 1 5 lanth tungsten 10pk

10 Pack 1 5 Lanthanated Tungsten Welding Rods 1 8x7 1 5 lanth tungsten 10pk

Reviews 10 Pack 1 5 Lanthanated Tungsten Welding Rods 1 8x7 1 5 lanth tungsten 10pk

Air Cooled TIG Torches 17fv 12 r flex torch

Air Cooled TIG Torches 17fv 12 r flex torch

Reviews Air Cooled TIG Torches 17fv 12 r flex torch

3 Triangular Sand Pad w Velcro Oscillating Multi Tool Saw Blades for Fein Multimaster Bosch Multi x Craftsman Nextec Dremel Multi max Ridgid Dremel Chicago

3 Triangular Sand Pad w Velcro Oscillating Multi Tool Saw Blades for Fein Multimaster Bosch Multi x Craftsman Nextec Dremel Multi max Ridgid Dremel Chicago

Reviews 3 Triangular Sand Pad w Velcro Oscillating Multi Tool Saw Blades for Fein Multimaster Bosch Multi x Craftsman Nextec Dremel Multi max Ridgid Dremel Chicago

Amp Air Cooled TIG Torch Package Torch Body W Flexible Head Long Back Cap Gas Valve Ribbed Handle 50 Rubber Jacketed Power Cab

Amp Air Cooled TIG Torch Package Torch Body W Flexible Head Long Back Cap Gas Valve Ribbed Handle 50 Rubber Jacketed Power Cab

Reviews Amp Air Cooled TIG Torch Package Torch Body W Flexible Head Long Back Cap Gas Valve Ribbed Handle 50 Rubber Jacketed Power Cab

150 Amp Air Cooled Torch Body With Flexible Handle

150 Amp Air Cooled Torch Body With Flexible Handle

Reviews 150 Amp Air Cooled Torch Body With Flexible Handle

Makita BO4556K 2 0 Amp 4 1 2 Inch Finishing Sander with Case

Makita BO4556K 2 0 Amp 4 1 2 Inch Finishing Sander with Case

Reviews Makita BO4556K 2 0 Amp 4 1 2 Inch Finishing Sander with Case

Series 1 Type MTHP Two Piece Cutting Tips 4 mth p cutting tip

Series 1 Type MTHP Two Piece Cutting Tips 4 mth p cutting tip

Reviews Series 1 Type MTHP Two Piece Cutting Tips 4 mth p cutting tip

DEWALT DWE6401DS 5 Inch VS Disc Sander with Dust Shroud

DEWALT DWE6401DS 5 Inch VS Disc Sander with Dust Shroud

Reviews DEWALT DWE6401DS 5 Inch VS Disc Sander with Dust Shroud

1 16 ER4043 AlcoTec Almigweld 4043 Aluminum MIG Welding Wire 1 Spool

1 16 ER4043 AlcoTec Almigweld 4043 Aluminum MIG Welding Wire 1 Spool

Reviews 1 16 ER4043 AlcoTec Almigweld 4043 Aluminum MIG Welding Wire 1 Spool

11GL53 5 32 Gas Lens Collet Body Set of 2

11GL53 5 32 Gas Lens Collet Body Set of 2

Reviews 11GL53 5 32 Gas Lens Collet Body Set of 2

A796F70 3 16 3 Standard Alumina Nozzle Set of 10

A796F70 3 16 3 Standard Alumina Nozzle Set of 10

Reviews A796F70 3 16 3 Standard Alumina Nozzle Set of 10

DELTA 17 940 25 Piece Sanding Drum Kit

DELTA 17 940 25 Piece Sanding Drum Kit

Reviews DELTA 17 940 25 Piece Sanding Drum Kit

Centerfire Diffusers large gas diffuser

Centerfire Diffusers large gas diffuser

Reviews Centerfire Diffusers large gas diffuser

400 PSI Delivery 2 Stage High Purity Stainless Steel Pressure Line Regulator With 4000 PSI Maximum Rated Inlet Pressure And Threadless Seat CGA 580

400 PSI Delivery 2 Stage High Purity Stainless Steel Pressure Line Regulator With 4000 PSI Maximum Rated Inlet Pressure And Threadless Seat CGA 580

Reviews 400 PSI Delivery 2 Stage High Purity Stainless Steel Pressure Line Regulator With 4000 PSI Maximum Rated Inlet Pressure And Threadless Seat CGA 580

PaceSetter by Goldblatt G15355 Plastic Pole Sander Head

PaceSetter by Goldblatt G15355 Plastic Pole Sander Head

Reviews PaceSetter by Goldblatt G15355 Plastic Pole Sander Head

23 Series Nozzles 23 50 nozzle Set of 2

23 Series Nozzles 23 50 nozzle Set of 2

Reviews 23 Series Nozzles 23 50 nozzle Set of 2

6 RTES Welding Nozzle

6 RTES Welding Nozzle

Reviews 6 RTES Welding Nozzle

DELTA 31 815 36 Grit Pre Cut Sanding Strips for Model 31 250 Wide Drum Sander

DELTA 31 815 36 Grit Pre Cut Sanding Strips for Model 31 250 Wide Drum Sander

Reviews DELTA 31 815 36 Grit Pre Cut Sanding Strips for Model 31 250 Wide Drum Sander

Porter Cable 846456 Sander Felt Pad

Porter Cable 846456 Sander Felt Pad

Reviews Porter Cable 846456 Sander Felt Pad